Squarespace Commerce analytics review

This review examines Squarespace Commerce analytics capabilities, design philosophy, limitations, and ideal use cases.

E-commerce analytics coverage

Revenue tracking: Total revenue, net revenue, order count, average order value. Revenue by category and traffic source. Basic segmentation but cannot drill into detailed campaign attribution.

Product analytics: Top products by revenue and units. Stock tracking. Limited trend analysis over time. Adequate for simple catalogs (20-50 products), insufficient for complex inventories.

Customer analytics: Customer list with orders and total spent. No lifetime value, purchase frequency, or segmentation. BigCommerce and Shopify provide these on base plans.

Traffic analytics: Visitors, page views, traffic sources. Minimal behavioral analytics. Good for content + commerce sites showing both blog and product performance.

Abandoned cart analytics (Advanced Commerce only)

Plan requirements

Advanced Commerce plan ($65/month): Includes abandoned checkout recovery and analytics. See abandoned checkout value, recovery rate, customer details.

Lower plans ($27-49/month): No abandoned cart analytics. Cannot see abandonment patterns or track recovery effectiveness. Critical feature gated behind premium plan.

Analytical depth

Metrics provided: Abandoned checkout count, total value, recovery emails sent, recovery rate. Basic abandonment overview.

Limitation: Cannot filter by abandonment stage (cart vs checkout), cart value, product, or time since abandonment. Less detailed than BigCommerce abandoned cart analytics. Functional but not sophisticated.

Interface design and usability

Design philosophy

Minimalist aesthetic: Squarespace applies signature design approach to analytics. Clean charts, generous white space, beautiful typography. Analytics dashboard looks elegant.

Visual clarity: Charts easy to read. Color schemes thoughtful. Information hierarchy clear. Design excellence makes data approachable for non-technical founders.

Trade-off: Prioritizing design simplicity sometimes limits functionality. Fewer filtering options, less drill-down capability, limited customization. Beauty over analytical depth.

Navigation and learning curve

Analytics location: Analytics panel accessed via left sidebar. Commerce section contains sales, inventory, orders. Site section contains traffic analytics. Logical separation.

Learning curve: 15-20 minutes understanding complete analytics interface. Simple enough for quick mastery but less intuitive than Shopify. More learning required than Shopify, less than BigCommerce.

Mobile analytics

Squarespace mobile app: View sales summary, recent orders, traffic overview. Mobile analytics adequate for high-level monitoring. Not as commerce-focused as Shopify mobile app but functional.

Real-time analytics limitation

Update delay

Dashboard lag: Analytics update with several hours delay. Today’s numbers might be 3-4 hours old. Slower than BigCommerce (real-time) and Shopify (1-2 hour delay).

Practical impact: Cannot monitor flash sales, campaign launches, or time-sensitive events effectively. By time analytics show problem, hours of suboptimal performance occurred.

Workaround: Check email notifications for individual orders. Provides order-level visibility but not analytical dashboard view. Operational awareness without strategic analytics.

Report customization and export

Customization limitations

Fixed date ranges: Standard periods only (7 days, 30 days, 90 days, year). Cannot create custom date ranges or period comparisons. Less flexible than Shopify allowing any date range.

Limited filtering: Basic filtering by product category or traffic source. Cannot combine multiple filters or create complex segments. Report viewing fixed by Squarespace design.

Export capability

CSV export: Can export customer lists, product sales, order history. Basic data portability for external analysis.

Limitation: Cannot export custom report views or filtered segments. Must work with full data exports and filter externally. More manual work than Shopify’s flexible export.

Integration and ecosystem

Third-party analytics integration

Limited ecosystem: Fewer analytics-specific apps or extensions compared to Shopify. Squarespace more closed platform. Limited analytics expansion options natively.

GA4 integration: Can connect Google Analytics 4. Requires manual code injection or extension setup. More technical than Shopify’s native Google channel. Workable but friction higher.

Email marketing integration

Squarespace Email Campaigns: Native email tool integrates with commerce analytics. See campaign performance, revenue attribution, customer engagement. Integrated ecosystem valuable for Squarespace-centric businesses.

External tools: Integrations with Mailchimp, Klaviyo exist but less seamless than Shopify ecosystem. Squarespace optimized for native tools over third-party extensions.

Pricing and plan considerations

Commerce plan analytics ($27/month)

Included: Basic commerce analytics. Revenue, orders, products, customers, traffic. No abandoned cart analytics. No advanced features. Entry-level analytics.

Advanced Commerce analytics ($65/month)

Added features: Abandoned checkout recovery and analytics. Advanced shipping and discount features. Subscription analytics for recurring revenue businesses.

Value consideration: $65/month expensive compared to Shopify Basic ($39/month) providing comparable analytics. Paying premium for Squarespace design and content integration, not superior analytics depth.

Ideal use cases for Squarespace Commerce

Choose Squarespace if:

Design priority: Brand aesthetics critical. Want commerce platform matching Squarespace’s design excellence. Analytics simplicity acceptable for design consistency.

Content + commerce: Running blog, portfolio, or content site with shop. Squarespace’s content management superior to pure commerce platforms. Integrated content and commerce valuable.

Creator monetization: Photographers, designers, artists selling work online. Visual presentation more important than analytical sophistication. Squarespace design showcases products beautifully.

Basic analytical needs: Revenue, orders, top products sufficient. Don’t need customer segmentation, deep attribution, or real-time monitoring. Simple reporting adequate for business needs.

Avoid Squarespace if:

Data-driven growth focus: Analytics central to business strategy. Need detailed product analysis, customer segmentation, attribution modeling. Squarespace analytics insufficient for sophisticated analysis.

Real-time monitoring needs: Run time-sensitive campaigns, flash sales, high-volume events requiring immediate feedback. Squarespace analytics delay problematic.

Large product catalog: Hundreds of products requiring detailed performance tracking, variant analysis, category trends. Squarespace product analytics too basic for complex inventory.

Frequently asked questions

How does Squarespace Commerce compare to Shopify for analytics?

Shopify provides deeper e-commerce analytics at lower price point. Shopify Basic ($39/month) includes customer segmentation, better product analytics, faster dashboard updates than Squarespace Advanced Commerce ($65/month). Squarespace wins on design aesthetics and content integration. Shopify wins on analytical depth and customization. Choose Squarespace for design-first approach. Choose Shopify for analytics-first approach. If analytics important to business strategy, Shopify superior choice despite less elegant design.

Can I use Google Analytics with Squarespace to improve analytics?

Yes. GA4 integration adds behavioral analytics, detailed attribution, advanced segmentation Squarespace lacks natively. Setup requires manual code injection or extension installation. More technical than Shopify GA4 setup but achievable. With GA4, Squarespace analytics gaps partially filled. But native Squarespace analytics still lag Shopify even with GA4 addition. GA4 improves Squarespace but doesn’t make analytics equal to Shopify. Consider whether adding GA4 complexity aligns with Squarespace simplicity philosophy.

Is abandoned cart analytics worth upgrading to Advanced Commerce?

Abandoned carts typically 3-5x completed orders. Tracking abandonment patterns and recovery effectiveness drives significant revenue recovery. If store has meaningful traffic (50+ daily visitors), abandoned cart analytics likely worth $38/month upgrade from Business Commerce ($27/month) to Advanced Commerce ($65/month). But consider alternatives: Shopify Basic ($39/month) includes abandoned cart analytics plus superior overall analytics. Upgrading within Squarespace costs more than switching to analytically superior platform. Evaluate total platform value, not just abandoned cart feature.

Peasy delivers automated email analytics for Squarespace stores—get daily performance summary without logging into dashboards. Starting at $49/month. Try free for 14 days.