Omnisend vs Klaviyo analytics: Which shows better insights?

Choosing between Omnisend and Klaviyo for e-commerce email marketing often comes down to analytics depth versus ease of use. Klaviyo provides more advanced customer segmentation and detailed behavioral analytics but requires technical comfort and time investment to master. Omnisend offers simpler interface with solid analytics suitable for most stores under $500k annual revenue, though with less granular customer data analysis.

This comparison focuses specifically on analytics capabilities—how each platform tracks, reports, and helps you understand email marketing performance.

Analytics dashboard comparison

Omnisend dashboard: Clean, scannable interface showing key metrics prominently. Campaign performance visible at a glance from campaign list. Reports section provides deeper analytics without overwhelming options. Learning curve: 15-30 minutes to understand all analytics features.

Klaviyo dashboard: Data-rich interface with extensive filtering and customization options. More metrics available but requires knowing what to look for. Steeper learning curve (2-4 hours) but rewards investment with powerful insights. Best for data-comfortable users.

Winner for beginners: Omnisend. Easier to find essential metrics without training. Winner for advanced users: Klaviyo. More analytical depth for optimization.

Revenue attribution and tracking

Omnisend attribution: Tracks revenue from campaigns and automations using 5-day attribution window. Shows total revenue, number of orders, and revenue per email. Attribution is straightforward—last click within window gets credit. Works well for most stores.

Klaviyo attribution: More sophisticated multi-touch attribution options. Can see first touch, last touch, or attribution across multiple email interactions. Tracks customer journey through multiple campaigns before purchase. Provides deeper understanding of how emails work together to drive sales.

Practical difference: For stores with simple customer journeys (browse, cart, purchase within days), Omnisend attribution suffices. For stores with longer consideration periods or complex multi-campaign journeys, Klaviyo’s attribution reveals insights Omnisend misses.

Automation analytics comparison

Omnisend automation reports: Shows performance for each automation workflow. Metrics include emails sent, open rate, click rate, revenue generated, and conversion rate. Can view individual email performance within workflows. Straightforward workflow optimization.

Klaviyo flow analytics: Similar workflow metrics plus customer progression through flows (how many enter, where they exit, time to conversion). More granular split testing for flow emails. Can analyze flow performance by segment (how VIP customers versus new subscribers respond to same flow).

Practical difference: Both platforms provide solid automation analytics. Klaviyo offers more granular analysis for optimization. For most stores, Omnisend automation reports provide sufficient data for effective optimization.

Segmentation and customer analytics

Omnisend segmentation analytics: Create segments based on purchase history, engagement, demographics. View campaign performance by segment. Solid segmentation for targeting campaigns effectively. Suitable for common e-commerce segments (VIP customers, engaged subscribers, cart abandoners).

Klaviyo segmentation analytics: Advanced behavioral segmentation using any customer data point. Track customer lifetime value by segment. Predictive analytics (likelihood to purchase, churn risk). Cohort analysis showing retention by acquisition month. Deep customer analytics rivaling dedicated analytics platforms.

Who needs Klaviyo’s advanced segmentation: Stores over $500k revenue where granular customer analysis drives significant optimization. Subscription businesses requiring sophisticated retention analysis. Stores with complex product catalogs needing behavioral product recommendations.

Who is fine with Omnisend segmentation: Most stores under $500k revenue. Stores with straightforward product lines. Teams wanting to spend less time on analytics and more time on execution.

Reporting and data export

Omnisend reporting: Standard reports covering campaigns, automations, subscribers, and revenue. Can export basic data to CSV. Reports are pre-built—less customization but faster access to common metrics.

Klaviyo reporting: Extensive custom report building. Can export detailed data for external analysis. API access for integration with business intelligence tools. More flexibility for custom analytics needs.

Practical difference: Omnisend reports handle 90% of e-commerce analytics needs with pre-built reports. Klaviyo suits stores needing custom reporting or integration with other analytics systems.

Pricing versus analytics value

Omnisend pricing: Pro plan starts $16/month (500 contacts), scales to $59/month (2,500 contacts), $99/month (5,000 contacts). All analytics features included at every tier. Predictable pricing.

Klaviyo pricing: Starts free (250 contacts), then $20/month (500 contacts), $60/month (1,500 contacts), $150/month (5,000 contacts). All analytics features included. Generally more expensive at similar contact counts.

Analytics ROI consideration: Klaviyo’s advanced analytics justify higher cost if you actively use them for optimization generating additional revenue. If you check basic metrics (open rate, revenue) weekly without deep analysis, Omnisend provides sufficient analytics at lower cost.

Which platform for your analytics needs?

Choose Omnisend if: You want straightforward analytics without overwhelming options. Your store is under $500k annual revenue. You prefer spending time on campaign creation over data analysis. You need simple segmentation (VIP, engaged, cart abandoners). Budget is constrained and you want analytics at lower price point.

Choose Klaviyo if: You’re comfortable with data and enjoy analytical work. Your store exceeds $500k revenue where granular optimization matters. You need advanced customer segmentation and predictive analytics. You want multi-touch attribution understanding complex customer journeys. You have team member dedicated to email marketing optimization.

Can use both? No. These platforms serve same function. Running both is redundant and expensive. Most common scenario: start with Omnisend for simplicity, migrate to Klaviyo when store growth and sophistication warrant advanced analytics.

Peasy automatically sends your key analytics to your team every morning—eliminate daily dashboard checks. Starting at $49/month. Try free for 14 days.