Tracking AOV: Best practices

Why tracking setup matters

Poor AOV tracking creates false conclusions and misdirected optimization. Including refunded orders inflates AOV making performance appear better than reality—you optimize based on $68 AOV when actual retained revenue is $62 AOV. Mixing time zones creates inconsistent daily comparisons—Monday appears weak because half the orders actually occurred Sunday night in platform timezone. Not segmenting by traffic source hides performance gaps—overall $58 AOV looks acceptable while social traffic generates unprofitable $32 AOV dragging down email's strong $75 AOV. Proper tracking setup provides accurate baseline preventing optimization based on flawed data.

AOV tracking seems simple—divide revenue by orders. But implementation details determine whether insights are actionable or misleading. Which revenue (gross, net, product-only)? Which orders (all, completed, retained after refunds)? Which timeframe (order date, payment date, fulfillment date)? What segments (source, device, customer type)? Answering these questions consistently creates reliable tracking foundation. Changing definitions mid-stream breaks trend analysis—was AOV increase real performance improvement or tracking methodology change?

Setting up accurate AOV calculation

Define revenue consistently

Most stores track AOV using product revenue only—excluding shipping charges, taxes, and discounts. Customer order: $85 products + $12 shipping + $7 tax - $10 discount code = $94 order total. AOV calculation: $85 (product revenue only). Why exclude shipping and tax? They're pass-through amounts, not controllable revenue. Why include discount impact? Discount reduces actual revenue received. Alternative approach: include everything (order total method). Same order = $94 AOV. Valid if you want total customer spend visibility. Most important: choose one method, document it, use consistently. Don't switch between methods—creates incomparable historical data.

Handle refunds and cancellations appropriately

Refunded orders should be removed from AOV calculation—they generated no retained revenue. Customer orders $92 Monday, refunds Wednesday = don't include in AOV. Platforms handle this differently: Shopify automatically adjusts historical reports removing refunded orders, Google Analytics typically doesn't adjust historical data (order tracked Monday stays in Monday's numbers even after Wednesday refund), WooCommerce Analytics varies by configuration. Know your platform's approach: test by completing order, immediately refunding, checking if it appears in current day's AOV. If yes, you need manual adjustment or accept 2-5% overstatement (typical refund rate).

Align timezone settings

Platform timezone determines which day orders count toward. Store timezone set to Pacific (UTC-8), customer in New York purchases 11:30pm Eastern (8:30pm Pacific) Monday. Platform records as Monday order. Same customer purchasing 12:30am Eastern Tuesday (9:30pm Pacific Monday) = platform records as Monday order despite being Tuesday for customer. Not wrong, just requires understanding—your Monday might include customer's early Tuesday purchases. Set platform to your operational timezone, then stick with it. Changing timezone mid-operation breaks day-over-day comparisons. Document timezone used preventing confusion when discussing daily metrics with team members in different locations.

Daily AOV tracking

Review yesterday's AOV with context

Check yesterday's AOV comparing to last week same day—not yesterday absolute versus random expectations. Monday $52 AOV means nothing without context. Monday $52 versus last Monday $58 = 10% decline, investigate if concerning. Monday $52 versus last Monday $48 = 8% increase, normal positive variance. Day-of-week comparison removes weekly patterns—Saturdays naturally run higher AOV (gift shopping, leisure browsing), Tuesdays often lower (workday, rushed purchasing). Compare Monday to Monday, Saturday to Saturday for meaningful daily tracking.

Spot catastrophic issues quickly

Daily tracking catches extreme anomalies indicating technical problems requiring immediate attention. Yesterday $28 AOV versus typical $58 = investigate immediately. Possible causes: checkout broken accepting partial orders, discount code error providing excessive discounts, pricing error displaying wrong prices, tracking error recording only portion of orders. Any 30%+ AOV decline in single day warrants immediate investigation—rarely natural customer behavior, usually technical malfunction. Set up alerts: if AOV drops below 70% of 7-day average, receive immediate notification.

Don't overreact to daily variance

AOV fluctuates 8-15% day-to-day naturally—small sample size creates noise. Monday 22 orders at $52 AOV, Tuesday 19 orders at $61 AOV isn't "Tuesday success"—normal variance from small daily samples. If Tuesday had 2-3 fewer low-value orders or 1-2 more high-value orders compared to Monday, AOV swings $8-12 easily. Daily tracking purpose: catch catastrophic failures, not analyze optimization impact. Week-over-week and month-over-month comparisons reveal real patterns—daily is too noisy for strategic decisions.

Weekly AOV analysis

Calculate 7-day rolling average

Seven-day window smooths daily variance revealing actual trends. Past 7 days: $58, $62, $54, $68, $59, $63, $57 daily AOVs. Average: $60.14 weekly AOV. Previous 7 days averaged $58.40. Week-over-week change: +3% (improving trend). Rolling average eliminates noise—if 4 of 7 days showed AOV around $58-62, that's your baseline regardless of outlier days at $54 or $68. Calculate weekly average, compare to previous week, track trend direction over 4-8 weeks identifying consistent improvement or degradation patterns.

Segment by major traffic sources

Weekly segmentation reveals source-specific performance. This week overall: $58 AOV. By source: Email $72 (+24% vs overall), Organic $61 (+5%), Paid search $56 (-3%), Social $38 (-34%). Analysis: email performs strongly, social significantly underperforms, organic and paid near average. Decision: grow email list (high AOV source), investigate social targeting or accept low AOV for awareness focus, maintain organic and paid. Without segmentation, you'd see acceptable $58 overall AOV missing $38 social problem and $72 email opportunity.

Compare to same week last year

Year-over-year comparison isolates real growth from seasonal patterns. This week: $64 AOV. Last week: $61 AOV (+5%, looks good). Same week last year: $59 AOV (+8% YoY, actual improvement). Month-to-month and week-to-week comparisons miss seasonality. November naturally shows higher AOV than October (holiday shopping). November 2025 versus November 2024 reveals whether you improved on same seasonal period—true performance measurement. Always include YoY perspective in weekly reviews when available (requires 12+ months operating history).

Monthly deep-dive tracking

AOV by traffic source with conversion rate

Monthly analysis pairs AOV with conversion rate revealing channel efficiency. Email: $75 AOV, 4.2% conversion, $3.15 revenue per session (RPS). Organic: $63 AOV, 2.8% conversion, $1.76 RPS. Paid: $58 AOV, 2.1% conversion, $1.22 RPS. Social: $42 AOV, 1.4% conversion, $0.59 RPS. RPS ranking: email dominant, organic strong, paid acceptable, social concerning. Without RPS calculation, you'd see AOV differences but miss conversion impact—paid's $58 AOV looks similar to organic's $63, but paid's lower conversion makes it 30% less efficient per session.

AOV by device type

Device segmentation reveals mobile-desktop gap and optimization priorities. Desktop: $72 AOV, 2.9% conversion, $2.09 RPS. Mobile: $52 AOV, 2.2% conversion, $1.14 RPS. Tablet: $64 AOV, 2.4% conversion, $1.54 RPS. Mobile AOV is 28% below desktop—normal pattern reflecting mobile browsing behavior and smaller screens limiting product visibility. If mobile represents 65% of traffic, mobile optimization becomes priority despite lower per-session metrics—volume makes efficiency gains valuable. Track whether mobile gap is widening (mobile experience degrading), stable (acceptable baseline), or narrowing (optimization working).

AOV by customer type and lifecycle

New versus repeat customer AOV reveals acquisition efficiency and retention value. New customers: $48 AOV, 850 orders. Repeat customers: $69 AOV, 320 orders. Repeat AOV is 44% higher—healthy pattern showing trust and familiarity enable larger purchases. Growing repeat customer percentage naturally increases overall AOV—traffic mix shifts toward high-value segment. If repeat AOV doesn't significantly exceed new AOV (less than 20% premium), investigate: limited product selection preventing expansion purchases? Poor first experience reducing return enthusiasm? Track repeat customer growth—more valuable than new customer volume for long-term AOV improvement.

Tracking AOV trends over time

Create rolling 90-day chart

Visualize AOV across 90-day periods removing monthly volatility. Chart showing: January $56, February $52, March $58, April $59, May $61, June $63. Pattern: dip in February (post-holiday), gradual recovery March-April, growth May-June. Trend is positive (+13% from January to June) despite monthly ups and downs. 90-day rolling view reveals directional trends without getting lost in monthly noise. Update monthly adding latest month, dropping oldest month, always viewing last 90 days. Trend visualization answers: are we improving, stable, or declining over time?

Set realistic growth targets

Established stores should target 5-10% annual AOV growth. Current $58 AOV, target $61-64 after 12 months. Faster growth (15%+ annually) is possible but risks conversion damage if pursued aggressively. New stores (under 12 months) often see 15-25% first-year AOV growth naturally—product line expansion, customer review accumulation, repeat purchases beginning. After year 2-3, growth slows to 5-10% range—already implemented easy wins, requires sophisticated optimization for incremental gains. Don't expect 20% annual growth perpetually—compounds to unrealistic levels (20% annual growth doubles AOV in 3.8 years, unrealistic for most categories).

Identify seasonal patterns for future planning

Multi-year tracking reveals predictable seasonal AOV fluctuations. November-December: AOV increases 20-35% (holiday gifting, bulk buying). January-February: AOV decreases 10-18% (post-holiday budgets tight, returns processing). March-April: recovery to baseline. Knowing seasonal baseline prevents misinterpretation—December $78 AOV versus November $62 is expected increase, not optimization breakthrough. December 2025 $78 versus December 2024 $72 is real 8% improvement. Use seasonal patterns for: promotional planning (push premium products in November-December high-AOV period), inventory planning (stock gift sets and bundles in Q4), optimization timing (test AOV tactics in high-AOV periods maximizing impact).

Tracking by segment combinations

Source-device combinations

Cross-segment analysis reveals nuanced patterns. Email mobile: $62 AOV. Email desktop: $85 AOV. Organic mobile: $48 AOV. Organic desktop: $69 AOV. Findings: device gap exists across sources but is more pronounced for organic (44% gap) than email (37% gap). Email subscribers purchase more confidently on mobile than cold organic traffic—familiarity reduces mobile friction. Insight: optimize mobile experience for email campaigns specifically (high-quality mobile traffic), less urgency for organic mobile (inherently lower intent). Cross-segmentation prevents one-size-fits-all optimization—different combinations need different approaches.

Product category by customer type

Category AOV varies by customer familiarity. Apparel new customers: $52 AOV. Apparel repeat customers: $78 AOV (+50%). Accessories new: $38 AOV. Accessories repeat: $42 AOV (+11%). Apparel shows large new-repeat gap (trust barrier for clothing purchases), accessories shows small gap (lower-risk category). Strategy: focus new customer acquisition on accessories (lower barrier to entry), encourage apparel upsells to repeat customers who've established sizing and quality confidence. Category-customer segmentation informs product mix strategy and promotional targeting.

Setting up automated tracking

Daily email with key metrics

Automated morning email delivering yesterday's AOV, conversion rate, revenue per session, top sources—eliminates manual dashboard checking. Email format: "Yesterday: $58 AOV (vs $61 last Monday, -5%), 2.4% conversion (vs 2.3%, +0.1pp), $1.39 RPS (vs $1.41, -1%). Top sources: Organic 45%, Email 28%, Direct 18%." Takes 30 seconds to read providing complete operational snapshot. Set up via: platform native features (Shopify, WooCommerce), third-party tools, or custom reporting. Passive delivery beats active retrieval—information arrives without effort, consumed quickly, maintains daily awareness without dashboard time sink.

Weekly summary with trends

Monday morning email with past 7-day summary and comparison to previous week. "Past 7 days: $62 AOV (+6% vs previous week), 2.6% conversion (stable), $1.61 RPS (+7%). Segment highlights: Email $78 AOV (best), Social $38 AOV (lowest), Desktop $74 AOV, Mobile $56 AOV. Top 5 products by revenue." Provides weekly context enabling informed decisions. Takes 2-3 minutes reviewing weekly summary identifying: emerging trends requiring investigation, stable performance confirming health, opportunities for focus based on segment analysis.

Monthly report with strategic insights

First of month comprehensive report: full month AOV with YoY and MoM comparisons, segment breakdown by source and device, AOV trend chart for past 90 days, conversion rate and RPS alongside AOV for balance check, top performing products and categories. Takes 15-20 minutes reviewing monthly deep-dive but informs strategic decisions: where to invest next month (high-AOV sources), what to optimize (underperforming segments), whether overall trajectory is healthy. Monthly depth balances daily/weekly operational tracking with strategic planning needs.

Common tracking mistakes

Tracking too many segments

Segmenting by source, device, customer type, product category, geography, time of day, landing page, and 10 other dimensions creates analysis paralysis without proportional insight. Every segment requires attention, interpretation, decision—cognitive overload limiting action. Better: track 3-4 key segments consistently providing clarity than 15 segments sporadically creating confusion. Essential segments: traffic source (where customers come from), customer type (new vs repeat), device type (mobile vs desktop). Additional segments belong in quarterly deep-dives or specific optimization projects, not regular operational tracking.

Not documenting methodology

Six months later comparing historical AOV, you've forgotten: does this include shipping? Are refunds excluded? Which timezone? What attribution window? Discrepancies appear—"Why does dashboard show $58 but export shows $62?"—wasting time investigating what's actually definitional difference. Documentation: write down exactly how AOV is calculated (revenue components, order inclusions/exclusions, timezone, attribution), store in accessible location, reference when questions arise. Prevents confusion, enables accurate historical comparisons, ensures team alignment on definitions.

Changing tracking platforms mid-stream

Switching from Shopify Analytics to Google Analytics or vice versa breaks trend analysis—platforms calculate slightly differently creating before-after discontinuity. Was AOV change real performance shift or tracking change artifact? When changing platforms: run both simultaneously for 30-60 days identifying baseline differences, document definitional differences causing variance, don't combine data across platforms in trend charts. If AOV is $58 in old platform and $62 in new platform for same period, note 7% difference—apply adjustment when comparing historical (old platform) to future (new platform) data.

Quarterly tracking audits

Verify tracking accuracy

Every 90 days confirm AOV tracking matches reality. Compare platform AOV to manual calculation: export order data for past 30 days, manually calculate revenue ÷ orders, compare to platform-reported AOV. Match within 1-2% = tracking works correctly. Variance over 5% = investigate discrepancy (refund handling, revenue definition, order filtering). Test: complete purchase yourself, verify it appears in analytics with correct revenue attributed properly. Catches tracking degradation from: theme updates breaking integration, plugin conflicts, platform changes, customization affecting data flow.

Review segment definitions

Confirm traffic source attribution remains accurate. Test: arrive from Google search, complete purchase, check attribution = organic? Arrive from email click, complete purchase, check attribution = email? Misattribution happens when: tracking parameters get stripped (order becomes "direct" instead of actual source), multiple sessions break attribution (visit Monday via email, purchase Tuesday directly, gets attributed wrong), cross-domain tracking fails. Quarterly audit verifies attribution accuracy enabling confident segment-based decisions.

Update baseline benchmarks

As business evolves, baseline expectations should update. Year 1: $48 AOV baseline. Year 2: improved to $58 AOV through optimization. Update targets: Year 2 baseline is now $58, target $61-64 for Year 3 (5-10% growth from new baseline). Don't keep using original $48 baseline—understates current performance and sets outdated expectations. Quarterly update: current trailing-12-month AOV becomes new baseline, set next quarter targets as +2-3% improvement (compounds to 8-12% annually). Progressive baseline prevents complacency and provides relevant context for current performance.

While your analytics platform provides detailed AOV tracking and segmentation, Peasy delivers your essential daily metrics automatically via email every morning: Conversion rate, Sales, Order count, Average order value, Sessions, Top 5 best-selling products, Top 5 pages, and Top 5 traffic channels—all with automatic comparisons to yesterday, last week, and last year. Automated AOV tracking without manual dashboard checking, maintaining best practices through passive delivery. Starting at $49/month. Try free for 14 days.

Frequently asked questions

Should I include shipping and taxes in AOV calculation?

Most stores exclude shipping and taxes calculating AOV from product revenue only—shipping and taxes are pass-through amounts, not controllable revenue. Exception: if shipping strategy is integral to your economics (free shipping always, or shipping as profit center), include it to see total customer spend. Most important: choose one method, document it, stick with it. Mixed approaches over time create incomparable data. Product-revenue-only is most common and recommended unless you have specific reason to track total order value.

How often should I check my AOV?

Daily 30-second review: confirm yesterday's AOV is normal, catch catastrophic issues. Weekly 3-minute review: 7-day average, segment by major sources, compare to previous week. Monthly 20-minute analysis: full segmentation, trends, strategic assessment. Quarterly 60-minute audit: verify tracking accuracy, review methodology, update baselines. This cadence maintains awareness without excessive dashboard time. More frequent checking wastes time analyzing noise. Less frequent checking misses problems accumulating unnoticed.

Why does my Shopify AOV differ from Google Analytics AOV?

Platforms calculate differently: revenue components (product only vs total), refund handling (immediate adjustment vs not), attribution windows (1 day vs 30 days), timezone differences. Small differences (3-8%) are normal. Choose one platform as source of truth—typically your e-commerce platform (Shopify, WooCommerce) since it has definitive order data—and use consistently. Don't switch between platforms or try to reconcile perfectly. Document which platform is official AOV source preventing confusion during analysis.

What segments should I track for AOV?

Essential segments: traffic source (organic, paid, email, social, direct), customer type (new vs repeat), device type (mobile vs desktop). These three dimensions reveal 90% of actionable patterns. Additional segments (product category, geography, landing page, time of day) valuable for specific optimizations but not daily tracking. Focus on 3-4 key segments consistently rather than 15 segments sporadically. Deep segmentation belongs in quarterly analysis or specific projects, not regular operational tracking.