The best KPIs to track during sales campaigns

Sales campaigns represent significant investments in discounted margins and marketing spend, yet many e-commerce stores evaluate their success using only total revenue generated during the promotion period. This narrow view misses crucial performance indicators that reveal whether your campaign actually built long-term value or just borrowed future sales at a discount. Understanding which KPIs to track during promotional periods helps you optimize campaigns for genuine profitability rather than vanity metrics that look impressive but damage your business.

The right campaign KPIs balance immediate performance with long-term health, measuring not just what customers bought during the sale but also what behaviors you influenced and how the promotion affects your business after discounts end. This guide identifies the essential metrics to monitor during sales campaigns, explains what each reveals about campaign effectiveness, and shows you how to use these insights to design increasingly profitable promotions.

💰 Revenue metrics beyond gross sales

Total revenue during a campaign tells you what you sold but not whether the promotion was profitable. Track net revenue after discounts to understand actual income, then subtract the marginal costs of goods sold to calculate gross profit. Many campaigns that look successful by revenue standards actually lose money when you account for the discounts offered and the cost of inventory sold at reduced margins.

Compare campaign revenue to baseline sales you would have achieved without promotion to calculate incremental revenue. If your normal daily revenue is $5,000 and you generate $15,000 during a sale day, only $10,000 represents incremental sales directly attributable to the promotion. The remaining $5,000 would have occurred anyway, meaning you offered discounts to customers who would have purchased at full price. This analysis reveals true campaign lift versus cannibalized regular sales.

Revenue per session shows how effectively your campaign messaging converts traffic into buyers. Calculate this by dividing total campaign revenue by sessions during the promotional period. Rising revenue per session indicates your offers resonate with visitors and your site experience successfully guides them to purchase. Declining revenue per session despite high traffic suggests messaging misalignment or technical issues preventing conversions despite promotional interest.

🎯 Customer acquisition and retention indicators

New customer percentage reveals whether your campaign attracts fresh buyers or primarily incentivizes existing customers to purchase sooner. Track the ratio of first-time purchasers to repeat customers during campaigns. Healthy acquisition-focused campaigns should attract 40-60% new customers, while retention campaigns naturally skew toward existing customer participation. If your campaign intended to acquire new customers but delivered primarily to your existing base, adjust targeting and messaging for future promotions.

Customer lifetime value by acquisition source matters more than immediate campaign revenue. Tag customers acquired during promotional periods and track their subsequent purchases, retention rates, and total spending over the following 6-12 months. Customers who only purchase during sales and never return at full price represent costly acquisitions that erode profitability. Conversely, campaigns that attract customers who make initial promotional purchases then return regularly at full price deliver excellent long-term value despite reduced first-order margins.

• New customer acquisition cost: Calculate total campaign spend divided by new customers acquired to determine whether promotional acquisition costs remain below sustainable thresholds relative to expected lifetime value.

• Repeat purchase rate post-campaign: Measure how many sale customers return within 30-90 days to gauge whether your promotion built lasting relationships or attracted one-time bargain hunters.

• Average days until second purchase: Track how quickly campaign customers return compared to non-promotional acquisitions to understand if discounts accelerate or delay subsequent purchases.

• Coupon dependency rate: Monitor what percentage of customers acquired during sales only return when you offer additional discounts, indicating potentially unsustainable promotion-dependent relationships.

📊 Conversion and engagement metrics

Campaign conversion rate shows how effectively your promotion converts browsers into buyers. Calculate separately from baseline conversion rates to isolate promotional impact. Strong campaigns might lift conversion rates by 50-100% or more compared to normal periods, indicating compelling offers and effective messaging. Modest conversion increases despite significant discounts suggest problems with campaign communication, site experience, or offer design that prevent full potential realization.

Add-to-cart rate reveals how many visitors engage with your promotion by adding items to their basket. Compare this against purchase completion rate to identify where promotional interest converts to actual sales versus where friction prevents transaction completion. High add-to-cart rates with low purchase completion indicate checkout issues, unexpected costs, or payment friction that sabotage otherwise successful campaigns.

Time on site and pages per session during campaigns indicate engagement quality. Visitors spending significant time browsing multiple products show genuine shopping interest, while quick bounces suggest promotional messaging attracted irrelevant traffic. Deep engagement without conversion might indicate indecision requiring additional trust signals, comparison information, or urgency messaging to close sales.

🛒 Product and inventory performance

Units per transaction measures whether campaigns increase basket sizes beyond attracting purchases. Successful promotions often encourage customers to buy multiple items, maximizing revenue extraction during discount periods. Track whether specific promotion structures like "buy 2 get 20% off" successfully increase units sold versus simple percentage discounts that reduce margins without changing purchase quantities.

Product mix during campaigns reveals what customers actually want versus what you hoped to promote. If your campaign intended to clear slow-moving inventory but customers primarily purchased bestsellers at discount, you're reducing margins on items that would have sold anyway while failing to achieve clearance objectives. Analyze which products drove campaign success and whether their performance aligns with strategic goals.

Inventory turnover during promotional periods should accelerate compared to normal rates, especially for campaigns designed to clear seasonal stock or discontinued items. Calculate sell-through rates for promoted products to determine whether discount levels were appropriately set. Products that sell out immediately suggest you left margin on the table with excessive discounts, while minimal movement indicates inadequate promotional appeal requiring deeper discounts or different marketing approaches.

💳 Profitability and margin analysis

Average discount percentage applied shows how much margin you sacrificed to drive campaign results. Compare actual discounts taken against planned promotional structures to understand whether customers maximized discount opportunities or if many purchased at lesser discounts than available. This insight helps refine future campaign structures, potentially reducing unnecessary margin erosion.

Contribution margin per order calculates revenue minus variable costs including product costs, payment processing, and shipping. This metric reveals true campaign profitability better than gross revenue. Some campaigns generate impressive sales volumes while producing minimal or negative contribution margins, making them unsustainable despite appearing successful. Ensure your campaign economics deliver acceptable margins even after accounting for all variable costs and discounts.

• Return on ad spend: Calculate campaign revenue divided by campaign-specific marketing spend to determine ROAS. Healthy campaigns should achieve minimum 3-4x ROAS to cover discounted margins.

• Cost per acquisition: Track total campaign costs divided by new customers to ensure acquisition economics remain profitable given expected customer lifetime values.

• Net profit impact: Measure actual profit generated after all costs to determine whether campaigns truly benefit your bottom line or just create the illusion of success through revenue volume.

📈 Post-campaign performance indicators

Sales velocity after campaigns reveals whether promotions cannibalized future revenue or built lasting momentum. Track daily sales in the week following campaign end compared to pre-campaign baseline. Sharp declines below baseline suggest the sale simply accelerated purchases that would have occurred later, while sustained elevated sales indicate genuine demand stimulation and customer acquisition that continues driving revenue beyond the promotional period.

Email engagement rates post-campaign measure whether promotional communications damaged or enhanced your subscriber relationships. Monitor open rates, click rates, and unsubscribe rates in the emails immediately following your campaign. Increased engagement suggests your promotion satisfied customers and built enthusiasm for future communications. Declining engagement or elevated unsubscribes indicate campaign fatigue or disappointment requiring messaging adjustments.

🎯 Setting campaign-specific KPI targets

Establish clear objectives before launching campaigns, then select KPIs aligned with those goals. Acquisition campaigns prioritize new customer percentage and CAC metrics. Clearance campaigns focus on inventory turnover and sell-through rates for targeted products. Retention campaigns emphasize repeat customer participation and incremental purchases from existing customers. Measuring against pre-defined targets prevents post-hoc rationalization of disappointing results and forces honest campaign evaluation.

Create campaign scorecards that balance immediate performance with long-term impact. Weight metrics based on strategic importance rather than treating all KPIs equally. A campaign that achieves modest revenue but attracts high-quality customers with strong retention potential might outperform a campaign generating higher immediate sales to one-time bargain hunters. Sophisticated evaluation recognizes these trade-offs and judges success against genuine business objectives.

Sales campaigns deserve rigorous performance measurement that goes far beyond counting revenue during promotional periods. By tracking the right KPIs throughout and after campaigns, you understand true profitability, customer quality, and long-term impact. This analytical approach transforms promotions from margin-eroding desperation tactics into strategic growth tools that build sustainable business value while generating immediate results.

Ready to track campaign performance comprehensively and optimize your promotional strategy based on real profitability? Try Peasy for free at peasy.nu and see exactly which campaigns drive genuine growth.